data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3037a/3037a7f43fa36822fd16b1e7e40ae41d964e2da7" alt=""
When I first tuned in I thought "you've got to be kidding me Mariah Carey night" eee gads. I think Simon said it best after David Cook "its been karaoke up until this point!"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0838a/0838afc7492c744f22bbc7b480b2d89d2ccd6eaa" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/364c1/364c10565bb7382418c39c1904613eb1f61ddebd" alt=""
David A, you have talent....but not like this.
Saesha, you're screaming gives me a headache.
Carly, you looked beautiful tonite and I'm sorry you weren't given props. BTW, you nailed it
Kristy Lee, you definitely stepped up..possibly too late for you my dear.
Brooke, you remind me so much of Sheryl Crow---loved it
Jason Castro---I was so blown away with David Cook I thought he was the last singer BB9 started and I don't think there's anyway you could pull it off--sorry dude
No doubt we're watching some pretty good talent, but I'm guessing its time to say goodbye to Jason Castro or Saesha. It's just time.
Who's your favorite and why?